When to replace vs repair
Replace if you see: alligator cracking across more than 30% of the surface, sinking sections (base failure), repeated patching that doesn't hold, or you're planning to sell within 2 years. Repair if cracks are isolated and the base remains intact.
Replacement project timeline
Day 1: Demolition and haul-off of existing surface.
Day 2: Excavation to base depth, grading.
Day 3–4: Compacted RCA base install, bedding sand layer.
Day 5–6: Paver install, cuts, Belgian block borders.
Day 7: Polymeric joint sand, edge restraints, final cleanup.
30-year cost comparison: asphalt vs paver
Asphalt: install $5,000, sealcoat every 3 years ($300 × 10 = $3,000), patch repairs ($2,000 over 15 years), full replacement at year 18 ($6,000). 30-year cost: ~$16,000.
Pavers: install $15,000, polymeric sand refresh at year 12 ($800), individual paver replacement as needed ($500). 30-year cost: ~$16,300 — and the driveway still has 20+ years of life.
Frequently asked questions
- Can you replace an asphalt driveway with pavers?
- Yes — we remove the existing asphalt, excavate to 10–12" depth, install fresh compacted RCA base, and lay your new paver driveway. Total project is typically 4–7 working days for a standard two-car driveway.
- How much more does a paver driveway cost vs a new asphalt driveway?
- Asphalt runs $7–$12/sqft on LI in 2026. Pavers run $20–$55/sqft. The premium is real, but paver driveways last 30–50+ years vs 12–20 for asphalt — over a 30-year cost cycle, pavers win.
- Do I need a permit to replace my driveway?
- Most LI towns require a permit for full driveway replacement, especially if curb-cut dimensions change. We file all permits as part of the project.